Uncategorized

The Girl Who Always Knew The Way

A story about fetal alcohol syndrome, what a mother was never told, and what early support can still do

Category: Defects at Birth  ·  Condition: Fetal Alcohol Syndrome (FAS)  ·  Location: Nellore district, Andhra Pradesh

EPISODE 1: WHAT SHE CARRIES

This story is about Priya, she is nine, and she has something that the other children in her village near Nellore do not. She can find her way. Not just the familiar paths, the red-dirt track to school, the shortcut past the neem grove to the ration shop, but new places too, places she has only been once. She files them, somehow, the way water files the shape of a vessel: she was at her mother’s sister’s house in another village two years ago and she still knows, without thinking, that you turn left at the yellow water tank and cross the canal before the second mango orchard. She knows which bus goes where; she knows that the road to the district hospital has a bend at the third kilometre that everyone misses and then has to double back from.

Her teacher Sudha noticed it first. She sent the class to find the community centre for a programme, and Priya, who cannot always remember the homework assignment or what she ate that morning, led twelve children directly there without pausing, through a part of the village she had been to once, months before.

Sudha watched this and thought: she is not what she looks like on paper.

This is the thing about Priya that takes time to understand. What she looks like on paper, the marks, the assessments, the teacher’s notes about inattention and repetition and the difficulty she has connecting today to yesterday, is not the whole picture. The whole picture includes the roads. It includes the particular, precise intelligence of a child who always knows, in physical space, exactly where she is.

It is a narrow band of gift. But it is hers, entirely and without ambiguity, and she knows it.

Fetal alcohol syndrome is a condition caused by alcohol exposure during pregnancy.

It is, among all the conditions described in this series, the only one that is entirely preventable, no genetic mutation, no infection, no metabolic accident. Only one cause: alcohol consumed during pregnancy crossing the placenta and reaching the developing brain of a child who cannot metabolise it.

The brain that forms in the presence of alcohol does not form the same way. The damage is to structure, neurons that do not migrate correctly, connections that are not made, regions that do not develop with the architecture they need. The corpus callosum, which connects the brain’s two hemispheres, is often affected. The frontal lobes, which govern executive function, planning, impulse control, connecting cause to effect, are frequently damaged. The effects are not uniform. Every child with FAS is different. What is consistent is that the damage is permanent, present from birth, and invisible to a first glance.

Priya’s face carries the physical markers that make FAS recognisable to someone trained to see them: a smooth philtrum, the groove between the nose and upper lip that in most people is a vertical ridge, but in Priya is flat, and a thin upper lip, and eyes that are slightly smaller than average. These features are subtle. They are not what most people see when they look at her. What most people see is a small girl with her mother’s dark eyes, who sometimes seems inattentive, who is good at finding her way.

The diagnosis came when Priya was seven, from a doctor at a district hospital conducting developmental assessments under a government programme. It came, as most diagnoses in this series come, later than it should have.

What was different about this diagnosis, what makes Priya’s story sit differently in this series, is that the question it raised was not only: why wasn’t she seen earlier? The question was also: what did her mother not know, and why didn’t she know it?

What Lakshmi was told during her pregnancy:

Take iron tablets. Come for the check-up at week eight. Take iron tablets. Eat enough. Rest.

What Lakshmi was not told:

Toddy or Kallu is alcohol. Toddy crosses the placenta. The baby cannot process what you process. There is no safe amount and there is no safe time.

Nobody told her this.

She drank toddy the way her mother had drunk toddy during pregnancy. The way the women in the settlement drank when the work was hard and the body ached and there was nothing else that cost less or was more available. Palm wine, four or five rupees a glass at the stall beside the highway. She did not think of it as drinking; she thought of it as getting through the day. She did not know there was a difference.

EPISODE 2: WHAT NOBODY SAID

Lakshmi was twenty-three when Priya was born. She had been working in agricultural labour since she was fourteen, her family was part of a community that moved with the seasons, following the groundnut harvest south in October, the paddy fields in January, the chilli harvest in April. The work was physical and paid poorly and the contractors did not ask after health. The settlement outside Nellore where her husband’s family had a small piece of land was the most permanent place she had known in years.

She had two antenatal check-ups. She should have had eight.

The anganwadi worker who was supposed to visit the settlement visited when she could, which was not often, because she was covering four hamlets with a list of a hundred and twelve women and children and no vehicle. When she came, she talked about nutrition. She talked about the iron tablets. She weighed the women and noted the numbers.

She did not ask about drinking. This was not because she did not know that drinking was harmful in pregnancy. It was because asking was complicated. The families drank. The men drank. The toddy stall was part of the economy of the settlement in a way that the anganwadi worker, who was from a neighbouring town and was not from this community, navigated carefully. She was there to give health advice. She was also there to maintain a relationship that allowed her to come back.

Nobody asked about alcohol.

Priya was not an easy baby. She cried with an intensity that Lakshmi describes as frantic,not about hunger or discomfort but something deeper, something the baby could not explain and Lakshmi could not reach. She did not sleep in the patterns that babies usually sleep in. She was difficult to soothe.

By the time Priya was two, the differences were visible in a small-village way, noticed by the women around Lakshmi in the half-voiced, unspecific manner of communities that see everything and name very little. She falls a lot, she is slow; she is not like the others. Lakshmi’s mother-in-law said the child had been marked at birth, a phrase that explained nothing but contained a kind of community knowledge, however misdirected: that this child had come into the world carrying something from before she was born.

She was not wrong.

Lakshmi did not think about the toddy. She had stopped drinking after Priya was born because there was no longer a reason to get through the day in the same way, because the baby was now the reason to get through the day and that was different. The connection between the pregnancy and the child, between the toddy and the flat philtrum, between the glass at the stall and the daughter who could not connect today to yesterday, had never been made for her. It could not be unmade if it was never made.

She carried a guilt she did not yet have the language for. A shapeless grief that attached itself to small things: the way she looked at the toddy stall now, the way she sometimes watched Priya struggling with something ordinary and felt something tighten in her chest that she could not name.

The name for it came two years later, in a district hospital, in a room with a government doctor who had a checklist and a diagram of a face.

What Lakshmi was told at the district hospital, Priya age seven:

This is called fetal alcohol syndrome. It is caused by drinking during pregnancy. The features you see, the face, the development, they come from that.

The doctor said this carefully. He was a careful man.

He said: it is permanent. The damage to the brain does not reverse. But with the right support, Priya can learn. She will need more time for things. She may need a different way of being taught, but she can learn.

Lakshmi went home and that night, after the children were asleep and her husband had gone out and the settlement was quiet except for the dogs and the highway sound, she sat outside on the step and cried in a way she had not cried since her own mother died, not for long, not loudly, but thoroughly.

She was not the kind of person who was given to self-pity. She had not had the conditions for it. She was the kind of person who got through things, which had always seemed like a virtue, until now.

EPISODE 3: WHAT CAN BE LEARNED

She made a plan and the plan looked like this:

It looked like telling Sudha the teacher. This was harder than it sounds, because telling the teacher meant saying the word, the sentence, the cause, in a village where everything is eventually known and knowing comes with its own economy of judgment. Lakshmi rehearsed what she would say for a week before she said it. She said it plainly: my daughter has this condition. It comes from something I did without knowing it was harmful, she needs more time for things, she needs to be shown things differently.

Sudha listened. She did not say the wrong thing, which was itself a kind of gift. She said: tell me what helps her.

This question, tell me what helps her, is one Lakshmi has since heard perhaps four times in nine years of raising Priya. Four times from professionals or teachers or health workers, in a life where most people either ignore the difficulty or explain it back to her as a problem that belongs to Priya alone.

What helps Priya:

Routine, carried in the body rather than stated as instruction. If the sequence of morning is always the same, her body knows it and her mind does not have to reach for it.

One thing at a time. Two instructions at once scatter but one at a time, she holds them.

Showing, not saying. If you describe the route in words, it is gone. If you walk it once with her, it stays.

Repetition without impatience. This is the hardest one for the adults around her, and the most important for her.

Time. More time than the classroom was designed for and more time than the system usually allocates.

Priya does not know she is different in the way that a diagnosis implies difference, as a fixed category, a named condition, a file in a government system. She knows she is different the way water knows its own temperature: not as a concept but as a felt fact, present and unremarkable.

What she knows with more certainty is the roads. She knows that she is the one who can be counted on to find the way. This has a social value in the village that she understands without being able to articulate: she is useful, specifically and reliably, in a way that cannot be dismissed. When the women from the settlement go to the district court building for a land dispute hearing and no one knows which lane has the right office, Priya  who was there once, two years ago, knows and she walked them directly there.

Fetal alcohol syndrome is not widely diagnosed in India. This is not because it is rare.

The global prevalence of FASD, the full spectrum, of which FAS is the most severe, is estimated at around 1 in 100 births. In communities with higher rates of alcohol use during pregnancy, it is higher. In India, awareness among healthcare providers is low, awareness among the public is lower, and there is no systematic screening. The diagnostic criteria require a trained clinician to recognise the physical features and conduct a developmental assessment.

What exists in many communities instead is a child who is slower, more difficult, harder to teach, labelled as intellectually disabled without a cause, or labelled as lazy, or simply managed around, accommodated without being understood.

The prevention is complete and the cost is zero: no alcohol during pregnancy. This requires that pregnant women know that toddy is alcohol. That local health workers ask the question that feels difficult to ask. That the conversation about alcohol and pregnancy reaches communities where alcohol is not seen as alcohol but as something ordinary, something the land provides, something the body needs to get through the day. It requires that someone say: this harms the child.

Lakshmi he says: if someone had told me, I would not have done it.

Priya is nine. She is in class four, one year behind standard progression, in a school that has, with Sudha’s advocacy, made small adjustments that have made a measurable difference. She still misses things. She still needs more time. She still cannot reliably connect what happened yesterday to what is expected today. But she can find her way.

She goes to the district hospital every six months for a developmental review. The doctor who sees her there has told Lakshmi that Priya’s profile, the specific way her brain compensates, the spatial memory that seems to route around the damage  is not unusual in children with FAS. The brain, he said, finds its way around the walls when it can, at least, it tries.

There is something Lakshmi has not said to Priya yet. She does not know when she will say it, or whether she will say it at all. She knows that the day may come when Priya is old enough to ask a version of the question, why am I this way, what made me this way, and that on that day an answer will be required.

What she has decided is this: she will tell the truth. She will tell it in the way that the district hospital doctor told her, without making the information a wound, without letting it become the whole story.

She will say: I did not know. I would have chosen differently if I had known. And you are here, and you are whole in ways that matter, and the roads know you, and that is all I need.

Fetal alcohol syndrome and fetal alcohol spectrum disorders (FASD) are entirely preventable: no alcohol during pregnancy means no risk. There is no safe amount of alcohol and no safe time during pregnancy to drink, this includes toddy, palm wine, home-brewed spirits, and any other form of alcohol. Many women in India are not told this clearly, or are told in terms that do not reach the forms of alcohol available in their communities. If you are pregnant, or planning to become pregnant, avoid all alcohol. If you are an ASHA worker, anganwadi worker, or health professional, please include this conversation in antenatal care, in plain language, without judgment, naming the specific drinks available in your community. Children who have already been affected by prenatal alcohol exposure can be helped significantly by early identification, developmental support, and adjusted teaching methods. If you are concerned about a child’s development and there was any alcohol use during pregnancy, ask a government health worker or paediatrician about a developmental assessment. The earlier the support begins, the more it helps.