Uncategorized

The Girl Who Memorised Everything

EPISODE 1: WHAT MEMORY IS MADE OF

Have you ever tried keeping a list? A to-do list? Or a shopping list? Well, this is a story about lists, because the first thing you should know about Zara is not the diet, it’s the lists.

She is four now, nearly five, and she has developed a system. Every morning before breakfast she tells her mother the names of every teacher in her preschool, in alphabetical order, including the one who left in September and has not been replaced. She has memorised the number plates of both cars on their street that belong to people she knows. She can recite the last three weeks of her mother’s grocery lists back to her, unprompted, with a precision that her mother Aisha finds slightly unnerving and mainly wonderful. Zara does not know she is doing anything unusual. She thinks this is how everyone’s brain works.

She has been on a special diet since she was eleven days old. She does not know what phenylalanine is. She does not know that it is in everything she cannot eat, the dal, the paneer, the egg, the dosa, and that if she ate those things, the part of her brain that is making the lists would, gradually and then less gradually, stop making them. She knows that she eats different food from her parents and from the children at school, and that there is a reason, and that the reason is something that will be explained more fully when she is older, which is the same thing her mother has been telling her since she was old enough to ask.

What she knows is her food, she knows its textures and its names. She knows which biscuits are hers and which are not, and she does not take the ones that are not, even when she is hungry and they are sitting on a low shelf and no one is watching. She knows she should say no if her aunt or uncle offere something that’s not a part of her diet. This is the particular discipline of a child who has understood, from the very beginning, that her body requires something from her. She has not yet decided what to feel about this. She is four, nearly five, there is time.

The condition is called phenylketonuria. Most people call it PKU. It is a genetic metabolic disorder, one of the oldest known, first described in the 1930s, in which the body cannot properly process phenylalanine, a common amino acid found in almost every protein-containing food. The enzyme responsible for breaking phenylalanine down, phenylalanine hydroxylase, is absent or severely reduced. The amino acid accumulates in the blood. It crosses the blood-brain barrier. In a developing brain, especially in the first years of life, when neural architecture is being laid down at a speed that will never be repeated, it causes damage.

Here is what is important about this: PKU is one of the few genetic conditions where the intervention is entirely dietary, not pharmaceutical. Reduce phenylalanine intake. Supplement with a specialised metabolic formula. Monitor blood levels. Begin in the first weeks of life. If you begin early enough, the brain is protected and the child develops. She makes her lists, goes to school, argues with her younger brother about which cartoon to watch, grows up.

If you begin late, or don’t begin at all, you cannot give those years back. You can give the diet now. It will stop the damage from worsening. What it cannot do is repair the architecture that formed in its absence. Zara was caught on day eleven. This is a sentence Aisha has said many times now. She says it with a particular expression, not quite relief, not quite pride, more the look of someone who has stood close enough to a different outcome that they still feel its weather.

How they got to day eleven is the part of the story she did not know she would have to fight for.

Aisha remembers the heel-prick test, of course, she does.

Zara was born at a private hospital in Hazratganj, Lucknow, a good hospital, a hospital that Aisha’s family had considered a responsible choice. The delivery was normal. Zara was healthy, good weight, cried immediately. On the second day, a nurse came and took a small sample of blood from the heel. She said it was a routine test. She said the results would be ready in a few days. She said someone from the genetics department would be in touch. Nobody told Aisha what they were testing for. Nobody told her what it would mean if the test came back abnormal. Nobody told her that if it did come back abnormal, speed was not a suggestion but a biological necessity, that every week in those first months was a week of brain development, and that phenylalanine did not wait.

The results came back on day nine. They came back to the hospital, and the hospital’s genetics department sent a report to Zara’s paediatrician. The paediatrician’s office called Aisha on day eleven and told her to come in.

In the auto on the way there, Aisha held Zara and thought: it’s probably about the weight. New mothers are always told something is about the weight.

EPISODE 2: WHAT THE BLOOD SAID

The number on the report was 32 milligrams per decilitre. Normal phenylalanine levels in a newborn are between 0.5 and 2 milligrams per decilitre. Anything above 4 triggers a follow-up. Anything above 20 is classified as classic PKU, the most severe form, requiring immediate and lifelong dietary management.

Aisha did not understand what 32 meant, because no one had told her what normal was. She sat in the paediatrician’s office with Zara in her lap and her husband Wasim beside her, and the doctor, a kind, careful man, but a man who had possibly given this kind of news many more times than he could count, explained what phenylketonuria was.

Aisha looked at Zara, who was looking at the overhead light with the particular absorption of an eleven-day-old discovering that the world has ceilings. Her world had different kinds of ceilings.

She has said, when talking about this later, that what struck her in that room was not fear, fear came later, but a very specific kind of cognitive dissonance. The baby in her arms was entirely perfect. She had ten fingers and ten toes and she had been feeding well and she smelled of milk and something warm and particular that Aisha had already decided was her favourite smell in the world. And the doctor was telling her that something about this perfect baby required immediate, urgent action, that they needed to start her on a metabolic formula today, that they needed to contact a metabolic specialist, that they needed to understand what she could and could not eat for the rest of her life, and that all of this needed to happen as fast as possible because her brain was growing right now, today, in this room, and the clock was not waiting.

It is a strange thing, to hold something entirely perfect and be told it is fragile. Not visibly fragile, not fragile in any way you can see, fragile at the level of chemistry. Fragile in a way that looks, from the outside, exactly like health. Aisha understood about the diet before she understood about the condition. The condition was too large, but the diet was something she could do. She asked: what can she eat?

The metabolic formula is not cheap. What the medical literature does not address at times is the cost of a lifetime on a specialised formula that is available at only a handful of pharmacies in Lucknow, that is not covered under most standard health insurance policies, and that a growing child requires in increasing quantities as she grows.

Aisha and Wasim are not wealthy. They are, in the way of many urban Indian families of modest income, managing. A government job for Wasim in the Lucknow municipal corporation. Aisha trained as an administrative assistant and takes pride to meet her dayghter between classes when Zara’s schooling allows. They had budgeted for a child. They had not budgeted for a child with a lifelong metabolic condition and a monthly formula cost that fluctuates with availability and that has, in certain months, meant choosing between Zara’s formula and other things that also felt non-negotiable.

They have not gone without the formula. They have arranged, in the creative and exhausting way of parents who have no other option, to never go without it. Extended family has been informed, one month at a time, Wasim’s mother, who disapproves of the diet on principle, she comes from a generation that understood eggs to be health itself, and who has had to learn, slowly and imperfectly, that her instinct about what to feed a child and the reality of what this child can eat are not compatible, and that love does not override biochemistry.

Zara has never had an elevated phenylalanine result. Every three months, a small tube of blood is sent to a metabolic centre in Delhi, there is no specialist in Lucknow who does routine PKU monitoring, and the results come back and they are good, and Aisha sends the number to Wasim in a message, and sometimes he sends back a single word and sometimes he doesn’t send anything, and she knows from the silence that he is doing the same thing she is doing, which is exhaling.

This is the life of managing a genetic condition, you become, because you have to, an expert in things you never expected to need to know.

Zara’s interior voice, when she thinks about food:

EPISODE 3: WHAT THE LISTS KNOW

There is a version of Zara who was not caught on day eleven. Aisha knows this version. Not in detail, she does not allow herself the detail, but in outline. She knows that without the heel-prick, the first indication of something wrong would probably have come around six months, when developmental milestones began to seem slightly off. The smiling is fine. The tracking is fine. But perhaps the babbling comes later. Perhaps the responsive quality, the sharpness, seems slightly muted, paediatrician might notice.

In most districts outside the major metros, PKU has no detection pathway. There is no routine newborn screening. The condition exists in families for years before a name is put to it, if a name ever is. A child who has been on a normal diet from birth, absorbing phenylalanine into a developing brain, does not present with something that looks like a genetic disorder. She presents with something that looks like developmental delay. Which is then addressed, or not addressed, through the interventions available for developmental delay: early childhood education programmes, speech therapy, the kinds of support that treat the symptom but have no mechanism for the cause. It is not that the children are not seen, they are seen. The question is what you see when you look.

This piece is the seventh in a series. The other stories follow children who were missed. Arjun, whose muscle weakness was called vitamin D deficiency for two years. Rohan, whose exhaustion was called laziness. Nandini, whose silence was called stubbornness. Bishal, whose bent legs were called family. Tanvi, who arrived at diagnosis early and has spent twenty years learning to live in a world that was designed for a different body.

Zara is different from all of them. Zara was not missed. Zara was found on day eleven, by a system that, that one time, in that hospital, on that day, worked.

Zara turns five in February. She has already announced that she wants a yellow cake and that she will make the list of who to invite, and that the list will be in order of how much she likes them, which is fair because she has explained it clearly enough that no one can object.

She goes to school in the mornings and comes home in the afternoons with her mother and tells her the numbers on the number plates she saw from the autorickshaw window. She is learning to read. She finds the shapes of letters interesting, she says the letter A looks like it is trying to be a tent, and this has become the family’s name for A now, the tent letter.

She does not know, yet, that her brain, the part that makes the lists, the part that noticed the tent in the letter A, the part that will grow into whatever she decides to become, was protected by a test she didn’t know she was taking, administered by a nurse she will never remember, on the second day of her life but Aisha knows.

She keeps the first result in a folder at the back of the wardrobe. 32 milligrams per decilitre, dated, with the hospital’s letterhead. She has not thrown it away and does not intend to. It is the number that marks the boundary between the life they have and the one that, in other circumstances, by other logistics, they might have been navigating instead.

But when February comes, and Zara makes her list of who to invite, in order of how much she likes them, and argues, successfully, for why the list system is fair, because she has already thought through all the objections and the list is the proof, every time.